Cloud Native Infographic

Don't Miss the "Cloud Native Infographic" !

Everything is cloud Native from 5G core to RAN, transport and orchestration. Either you know about it or Nothing about Cloud. In this "FREE" one page infographic poster, I have made it a QUICK and EASY reference for Cloud Native main concepts which are otherwise very complex to understand. Plus get notified when important blogs are published.

Optical ASON or Electrical ASON!

The debate still lingers on. When it comes to protection and re-routing  on High speed links, what is the benefit of using Optical ASON versus Electrical ASON.

The Optical ASON relates to lambda switching ( Also called WSON-Wavelength Switched Optical Network). This necessitates the need of using at  minimum Multi degree and directionless functionality. Using colorless functionality gives more degree of freedom and flexibility since in case of non-availability of a particular wavelength, ROADM has the functionality to change the color of wavelength also. When it comes to Electrical ASON, it is referred to as “ODU switching” at electrical layer of OTN switch. This necessitates the use of OTN switch along with ROADM. While Optical ASON gives one an advantage of lambda switching; the Eletcrial ASON gives advantage of control over more granular traffic at ODU level going as low as 1G traffic. In contrast, lambda switching can help to save on transponder resources because the same transponder can change direction or color thus there is no need to have multiple transponders for multiple restoration paths-a  benefit not available on electrical ASON which would need multiple lambda paths to be created from Day one. Electrical ASON on the other hand gives much faster restoration times compared to Optical ASON. So what is the verdict ?

The rule of thumb is following: If traffic granularity is less and the lambda is not filled completely, Electrical ASON is much more optimized and cost efficient, on the other hand if lambda is filled with traffic ( multiple ODUs occupying complete lambda)  that needs same SLA of restoration ( Meaning complete Lamda needs to be switched) then Opitcal ASON is much more optimized and cost efficient and ends up saving on the number of transponders.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
31 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ashish Batajoo
Ashish Batajoo
5 years ago

Hello Faisal,
what about electrical ason for 100ge? is it better than optical ason for long hub for 100g lambda system? or same as optical ason requiring regenerator if optical parameters not optimal.
as multiple 10g to different direction are regenerator as each add\drop nodes.

br,
ashish

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
5 years ago
Reply to  Ashish Batajoo

Hi Ashish,

100GE ASON will only make sense if the lambda is 400G or above. Currently I dont see any value if the lambda is 100G.

Ashish
Ashish
5 years ago
Reply to  Faisal Khan

Thanks Faisal for your reply. Does optical ason can gurantee under 50ms protection with 1+1+r and 1+1 protection.

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
5 years ago
Reply to  Ashish

You will use ASON mainly for restoration and not protection. Any 1+1 protection will guarantee 50 ms. 1+1+r will guarantee 50 ms even for more than 1 fiber cut.

Mohsin
3 years ago
Reply to  Faisal Khan

Dear Faisal:
we can use optical ASON for working + Protection if in case we use transponder level protection.
correct me if i am wrong

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
3 years ago
Reply to  Mohsin

you can configure two transponders ( working and protection) seprately in optical ASON mode. So that means yes to your answer.

Ramon
4 years ago

Hi there, after reading this amazing article
i am also delighted to share my familiarity here with mates.

Mary
Mary
4 years ago

Good Day

Please advise if Optical ASON is exactly the same as WSON as there is no clarity. Can you explain why you state that they are the same? thanks

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
4 years ago
Reply to  Mary

Thanks Mary,

The right name should be WSON. As WSON is a standard but optical ASON is just an industry term. But the industry is using the word interchangeably. Yes they are same but a word of caution. Sometimes the vendor would use the word optical ASON to mean that they support optical control plane without satisfying the detailed framework of WSON. For example WSON would mean that the equipment can switch based on optical impairments also in addition to fiber cut. Some vendors dont support switching on optical impairments. therefore they prefer to use the word optical ASON instead of WSON as then they just support a subset feature of WSON but not full WSON.

Vinod
Vinod
4 years ago

What are the switching times for both the technologies?

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
4 years ago
Reply to  Vinod

In general the restoration in Optical ASON is slower, may be in minutes. In electrical ASON, I have seen close to 200 msec or more.

Marcos
3 years ago
Reply to  Faisal Khan

Hi Faisal, how many simultaneous circuits are tipically restored <200ms for OTN ASON?

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
3 years ago
Reply to  Marcos

Thanks Marcos, depends, as it is also dependent on how much bandwidth is available for restoration.

Abhay
Abhay
3 years ago

I am having 40 channel 100G OTN with 6 directions. Its having UXU2 (Cross connect card) which connects service cards to Transponder. This OTN also have WSS8 card. We r using 2 channels 39,40 in each direction. I want to know in case of fiber cut in 1 direction how will the WSS switch the traffic to other direction as we r using same 39 and 40 channel in each direstion.

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
3 years ago
Reply to  Abhay

Dear as you are using OTN, so in this case you dont need to use WSS switching. As OTN swithing is enough. You are using electrical ASON and not optical ASON

Abhay
Abhay
3 years ago
Reply to  Faisal Khan

Thanks for ur prompt reply. I am new to OTN. We r using Fiberhome FONST 5000. I want to ask if we r using electrical ASON, then why did the pair of WSS8 and ODU8 used in the WDM shelves. The WSS is interconnected to all other 5 direction WDM’s WSS. Also, does the 4 UXU2 cards will be able to ASON the 40x100G data in case of fiber cuts?

Vishal sharma
Vishal sharma
3 years ago
Reply to  Abhay

Hello Abhay,

As far as the FONST 5000 concern it’s only support DWDM, and its upgrades version U20 is having OTN feature, now answer to your question, they are using a pair of WSS and ODU in every direction to make it fully functional ROADM configuration, also you must be using 1 or 2 pair for local add drop as well. So you can understand like that directions or path calculation can be done by WDM cards and switching and restoration is being carried out by UXU2.

Abhay
Abhay
3 years ago
Reply to  Vishal sharma

Hi Vishal
We are using 2 Lambdas in each direction and all the lambdas terminates at U20 rack using 1LN4 transponder card.
Is this ROADM dynamically reconfigurable or manual configuration is required, if more lambdas were used and switched using WSS?

Mohammad Hamed Arezoomandan
Mohammad Hamed Arezoomandan
2 years ago
Reply to  Abhay

Dear ABHAY

I hope all is fine
could you please give me information about cross connection of U20/U60 product of Fiberhome ?

mera
mera
2 years ago

is restoration time differ according to ason level (diamond -gold -servrr…)

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
2 years ago
Reply to  mera

Hi, yes it is

Arun Pandian
Arun Pandian
2 years ago

Hi Faisal,
Thanks for your post..
Could you please explain importance or need of using GMPLS protocol? what does it do?What are the parameter concept based Both Lambda / ODU switching happening?

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
2 years ago
Reply to  Arun Pandian

GMPLS is a generalized MPLS which can used anything as resoure for labeling. In case of DWDM , the resource is lambda, in case of OTN , it is ODU.

Arun Pandian
Arun Pandian
2 years ago

Hi Faisal,
I have a doubt in ROADM-Reconfigurable optical ADD/Drop Multiplexed.
I have a ROADM Mux ,its connected to 3 different direction lambda(different colour,A,B,C).Assumption: Each lambda capacity 10G.’A’ lambda carrying 10G full traffic, B & C lambda carrying 5G traffic compared to less traffic in A. Now A lambda carrying 10G got failure, So now ODU traffic will be switch over to rest of the B & C lambda(different colour).

In this scenario, Is protocol decide to switch the Shared traffic to different Colour Lamba? And also this switching will be happened automatically or manually?
Kindly advice.

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
2 years ago
Reply to  Arun Pandian

ROADM may do optical GMPLS, therefore it will switch full 10G switch, rather than sub lambda switching

Mohammad Hamed Arezoomandan
Mohammad Hamed Arezoomandan
2 years ago

Dear Faisal

I hope all is fine
many thanks for amazing article
Could you please give me information about FONST5000 Fiberhome and implementation of wson and ason in this equipment

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
2 years ago

Thanks Mohammad, Really have no idea about this product

Mohammad Hamed Arezoomandan
Mohammad Hamed Arezoomandan
2 years ago
Reply to  Faisal Khan

Dear Faisal
Many thanks for your attention
if possible please give me information about GMPLS and how the vendors used this protocol for switching

Muhammad Yasir Shamm
Muhammad Yasir Shamm
2 years ago

Thanks Faisal for an informative article. Can you please write an article on DWDM vs OTN (Optical and Electrical Sub layers and switching technologies use in both) and also Muxponder vs Transponder

Mostafa
Mostafa
1 year ago

Hi there,
Thanks for the post but I just had to mention that I found another copy of the same article with minor alternation at older date but from another author and it would be better if the copyright of the original author is maintained, you may check the below link:
https://support.huawei.com/huaweiconnect/carrier/en/thread-120775-1-1.html

Faisal Khan
Faisal Khan
1 year ago
Reply to  Mostafa

Thanks Mostafa, My post was published way back in 2013, before the post appeared on Huawei support forum. I will have to reach out to Huawei to raise this issue. Thanks for bringing this up.

31
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x